How did the “Assumption of Mary into Heaven theory” come about?


Q: How did the “Assumption of Mary into Heaven theory” come about?

A: It’s more than a theory. It’s an official dogma of the Catholic Church, and one of only two Ex Cathedra, infallible statements ever proclaimed by the Pope, throughout the history of the Church.

There are a number of valid theological reasons for the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary, as well as earlier scriptural precedents for it in the apparent bodily “translations” of Enoch, Elijah, and possibly even Moses.

It is known from scripture that Satan spared no effort trying to locate and claim the dead body of Moses, as some sort of a “trophy” … finally being frustrated by the concerted efforts and strong rebuke of Michael the Archangel.

Knowing this, if you were Jesus, King of Kings and Lord of Lords, triumphantly returned to Heaven after your successfully completed mission, but knowing full well that Satan, while officially powerless, still remained a dangerous fugitive back on earth, how long would you permit Satan to have his way with your own mother?

Then there’s the traditional explanation:

A number of the apostles witnessed Mary’s apparent death. Her body was placed in a tomb, and several days later, the tomb was found to be empty, her body seemingly replaced by a huge volume of flowers.

Some time later, St. John received the Book of Revelation from Jesus Christ, and John correlated the images and events in the last part of chapter 11 and the first part of chapter 12 with the events surrounding the “dormition” of the Blessed Virgin.

Based on this, the Catholic Church has always understood that God would not allow the sanctified flesh that was used to fashion Christ’s human body to see the corruption of the tomb. And since Mary, by special privilege of God, was necessarily sinless from conception, and further sanctified by some 34 years of dwelling in the immediate presence of Christ himself, there was absolutely no need for Mary to await the resurrection, since according to God’s grace, Mary had absolutely no sin that would warrant divine judgment … or death … for that matter.

The Church authoritatively and dogmatically explains all of this here, much better than I have, complete with extensive citations:…

But this short excerpt from the above document sums things up pretty well:

40. Hence the revered Mother of God, from all eternity joined in a hidden way with Jesus Christ in one and the same decree of predestination,(47) immaculate in her conception, a most perfect virgin in her divine motherhood, the noble associate of the divine Redeemer who has won a complete triumph over sin and its consequences, finally obtained, as the supreme culmination of her privileges, that she should be preserved free from the corruption of the tomb and that, like her own Son, having overcome death, she might be taken up body and soul to the glory of heaven where, as Queen, she sits in splendor at the right hand of her Son, the immortal King of the Ages.(48)

And as St. John explains at the end of his gospel, there was indeed a whole lot of very significant, authentic stuff going on, that never made it into the Bible.

Believe it … or don’t. (Catholics are required to believe it.)……


  1. Required? Really? There is no freedom of opinion?

    • Certain things are required matters of faith for all Catholic everywhere, are not optional, and are not subject to anyone’s personal opinion.

      This is definitely one of them.

      You can have your own opinion about it, but you can’t be authentically Cathoilc and have your own opinion about it. That position would make you a heretic, and we all know what happens to unrepentant heretics.

      • Lord Have Mercy….let’s not ‘judge’ who’s ‘authentically Catholic’ or not…The Bible’s the ‘tell all end all’ more than any pope, etc. that we know….though God Bless them Holy Called folk n the priests n such, and good point on john’s Gospel’s ch20 n 21 end notes basically, that so much more went on! though their focus was more on Jesus’ stuff….mary done a good thing By GOD, n bein’ there even at the end before The New Beginning God Willin was somethin’, n her intercessions, even ‘appearances’ on behalf of her Son and God’s Word….oofa, but we must remember even what the point of all that was, Salvation and Love for her Son, who In Turn also Directs folks towards GOD, Through Spirit, Communion/Eucharist, Baptism, repentance, etc. He (GOD; Father, Son, Spirit) is the main focus and Mystery of Christian life, the important points, The Way Truth And Life (jn.14 thanks be to GOD), but praise God for mary for her bold n brave choice, for believing, and st. joseph as well for that’s how this all God Willing Came to Pass Alleluia

        do you know where the lillies,etc. ‘traditional’ account came from? i’d be an interested catholic to know ^.^t

        mary was a wonderful example of obedience and joy, and God Willing now sharing in her Son’s Glory By GOD, intercessing for us God Willing as we should/do each other ^.^t praise The LORD PLGB

  2. you know i was born and raised a catholic but some of this drives me crazy, mary was asked to serve the Lord in her way as we were all asked to serve the Lord. some of us do and some of us fall short,but neither is of less value to jesus. he loves us all the same, jesus resurrection is the proof of life after death. jesus is the only way to the father. some of this needs to stop. i am really worried about idols, i think all that a person has put on mary is crazy. i admire her strengh and courage and her desire to serve the Lord but when did God appear to anyone and tell them mary is in heaven in bodily form. why can i not get an answer from any one on this, dates times and too whom did an angel or jesus appear to someone and give them this knowledge. the pope says that no son would want his mother to suffer and we all know jesus has never said life was with out pain and suffering for him. he lets us all suffer. I would like an honest answer to this question

  3. Excellent! Thank you.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s